The retail proprietary trading (“prop trading”) industry has grown significantly in recent years, emerging as a global market attracting aspiring traders seeking access to substantial trading capital without committing significant personal funds. However, despite its rapid expansion, the sector continues to operate within an uncertain regulatory environment.
A key question remains: How do retail proprietary trading firms fit within the existing financial regulatory framework?
Recent comments by Dr George Theocharides, Chairman of the Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) and Chair of ESMA’s Risk Standing Committee, provide insight into the current European regulatory landscape. While retail proprietary trading is not presently a key priority on ESMA’s agenda, the evolving nature of the sector suggests that regulatory discussions are likely to continue.
An Expanding Industry Facing Regulatory Uncertainty
The growing popularity of prop trading has attracted considerable commercial interest, particularly among younger generations seeking opportunities to access larger trading accounts through evaluation programmes.
Despite this growth, many firms continue to operate without financial services licences, maintaining that their activities are limited to educational services and simulated trading environments rather than regulated investment activities.
However, as business models become increasingly sophisticated, the distinction between simulated trading, financial services and other commercial activities is becoming less straightforward.
ESMA’s Current Regulatory Approach
According to Dr Theocharides, ESMA is not currently engaged in substantive discussions specifically concerning retail proprietary trading. Although the sector remains within the broader scope of market monitoring, it has not yet emerged as an immediate regulatory priority.
Nevertheless, this should not be interpreted as formal regulatory acceptance of existing business models or confirmation that they fall outside applicable financial legislation.
Rather, the current position reflects a cautious approach while authorities monitor market developments and assess whether further regulatory action may eventually be required.
The Blurring Boundaries Between Prop Trading and Brokerage Services
One of the principal regulatory challenges facing the industry concerns the classification of proprietary trading activities.
Many firms argue that traders pay for access to evaluation programmes and simulated trading environments, rather than investing in financial instruments or receiving regulated investment services.
However, an increasing number of operators are expanding beyond traditional evaluation models by acquiring regulated brokerage businesses, establishing their own licensed entities or integrating brokerage services into their operations.
This convergence raises important questions about the regulatory treatment of firms that use evaluation programmes to introduce successful participants to regulated investment services.
Where a business effectively operates as a customer acquisition channel or intermediary for brokerage activities, its overall structure and activities may require closer regulatory examination.
Consequently, firms should not assess their regulatory position solely by reference to their evaluation programmes, but should consider their entire business model and the nature of the services they provide.
Business Sustainability and Market Consolidation
The industry’s commercial sustainability presents another important consideration.
Many prop trading firms operate evaluation-based revenue models, under which participants pay fees to complete trading challenges, with only a relatively small proportion progressing to funded arrangements and receiving payouts.
Combined with increasing competition, technological costs and platform restrictions, these commercial pressures have contributed to significant market consolidation.
The 2024 withdrawal of MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 access from numerous proprietary trading firms following MetaQuotes’ licensing decisions further accelerated these developments. Some operators exited the market, while others migrated to alternative platforms or explored obtaining regulatory licences.
These developments demonstrate how commercial pressures and regulatory considerations increasingly influence the industry’s future.
Regulatory Developments in the United States
While European authorities currently appear to be adopting a monitoring-oriented approach, developments in the United States indicate a potentially different regulatory trajectory.
Following increased regulatory attention, including the widely publicised enforcement action involving My Forex Funds, certain proprietary trading firms have explored registration with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).
This suggests that some industry participants are proactively reconsidering their operating structures to address potential regulatory requirements.
Whether European regulators will eventually adopt a comparable approach remains to be seen.
Marketing Practices and Consumer Transparency
Marketing communications represent another area requiring careful consideration.
Some proprietary trading firms use expressions such as “Funded Accounts” and “Professional Traders”, or promotional messages suggesting that participants manage substantial real trading capital.
Where such terminology creates a misleading impression about the actual nature of the services offered, firms may face legal and reputational risks.
Businesses should therefore ensure that their marketing materials accurately distinguish between simulated trading activities and live trading arrangements, clearly explain programme conditions and avoid presenting hypothetical or simulated results as actual investment performance.
Transparency in customer communications should remain a priority, irrespective of whether a firm is currently subject to specific financial services licensing requirements.
Is Prop Trading Financial Services, Education or Gaming?
The fact that participants pay fees, operate under predefined rules and may receive financial rewards introduces additional complexity into this assessment.
Depending on the structure and operation of a particular programme, questions may arise as to whether it constitutes an educational service, a financial activity, a gaming-type arrangement or a distinct commercial model.
Ultimately, the regulatory classification will depend on the specific characteristics and substance of each business model, rather than the terminology adopted by the operator.
What Should Proprietary Trading Firms Consider?
Although no dedicated, comprehensive EU regulatory framework currently governs retail proprietary trading firms as a distinct category, businesses should not assume that their existing structures are automatically outside financial regulation.
Firms should proactively assess their activities, including:
- Whether their business model involves activities potentially falling within regulated financial services.
- Whether their marketing and customer communications accurately represent the services provided.
- Whether their contractual documentation adequately explains the simulated nature and conditions of trading programmes.
- Whether their relationships with regulated brokers create additional licensing or compliance considerations.
- Whether anticipated regulatory developments could affect their existing operations.
The absence of sector-specific regulation should never be interpreted as the absence of legal obligations.
How Psillidou Law Can Assist
At Psillidou Law, we provide tailored legal and regulatory advice to businesses operating in the financial services, fintech and proprietary trading sectors.
We assist clients in navigating complex regulatory requirements, assessing potential legal exposure and developing business structures that support their commercial objectives while addressing applicable compliance obligations.
Our services include:
- Regulatory assessments and legal opinions: Evaluating whether proposed or existing proprietary trading models fall within the scope of applicable legislation, including MiFID II and relevant Cyprus and EU financial services regulations.
- Regulatory gap analyses and risk assessments: Identifying potential compliance gaps and assessing regulatory risks.
- Corporate and business structuring: Advising on the establishment, development and restructuring of proprietary trading businesses.
- Licensing and regulatory exemptions: Assessing applicable authorisation requirements and potential exemptions.
- Contractual documentation: Drafting and reviewing trader agreements, evaluation programme rules, platform terms and conditions, customer disclosures and related documentation.
- Regulatory engagement: Assisting with communications and interactions with competent regulatory authorities.
- Ongoing legal support: Providing continued legal and regulatory guidance to fintech companies, investment firms and other financial services businesses.
Obtaining appropriate legal advice at an early stage can help businesses identify regulatory risks, make informed strategic decisions and establish a more sustainable operating framework.
Whether you are considering entering the proprietary trading market, expanding an existing operation or reviewing your current business model, Psillidou Law can assist you in navigating the relevant legal and regulatory considerations.
Contact our team to discuss how we can support your business.

Disclaimer: This article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No action should be taken or omitted based on its contents without seeking appropriate professional legal advice.
Source: Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC): https://www.cysec.gov.cy/CMSPages/GetFile.aspx?guid=ee284db7-f27e-457c-b368-d1503943fe38